The contributing authors question whether a core set of conservative principles can be determined based on the frequently diverging perspectives of these key philosophers. Get A Copy. Hardcover , pages. More Details Other Editions 4. Friend Reviews. To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.
To ask other readers questions about The Dilemmas of American Conservatism , please sign up. Be the first to ask a question about The Dilemmas of American Conservatism. Lists with This Book. This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Community Reviews. Showing Rating details.
Sort order. May 10, Brian Collins rated it really liked it. The essays collected by Duetsch and Fishman investigate tensions within American conservatism by looking at key figures in its 20th century history. In an introductory essay Fishman and Deutsch argue that conservatism is not monolithic but contains three competing strains: traditional, laissez-faire, and neoconservatism. The traditionalist conservative finds his roots in Aristotle and Edmund Burke.
They value histor The essays collected by Duetsch and Fishman investigate tensions within American conservatism by looking at key figures in its 20th century history. They value historical communities and institutions and are concerned about individualistic and libertarian ideologies that undermine them. They emphasize the rule of law as necessary to secure liberty; the role of "aristocracy" in providing moral example; liberty and the individual exist in a social context.
They affirm the existence of natural law.
Hayek stands as the exemplar of laissez-faire conservatism. Many conservatives are traditional in the social realm and laissez-faire in the economic realm, but others apply the laissez-faire philosophy across the spectrum of life. In this approach, liberty is defined as "the state in which a person is not subject to coercion by the arbitrary will of another. The supreme good emerges for Hayek when there is the absence of external restraints. Social justice or equality is a delusion; they only serve to diminish freedom. A free society is self-adjusting, leading toward greater productivity and public order, and this means inequality.
Such a robust view of freedom makes the claim that the freedom to pursue one's private vices, such as greed, will somehow produce public benefits. Traditional conservatives and laissez-fair conservatives inevitably find themselves in conflict over the issue of amoral capitalism" p. The principles of agrarianism i. Traditionalists defend classical Western civilization and value an education informed by the texts of the Hebraic , Greek , Roman and Medieval eras.
Similarly, traditionalists are classicists who revere high culture in all of its manifestations e.
- The University Press of Kentucky - About the Book.
- The Prophet Muhammad: A Biography;
- Y ahora, Buenos Aires (Spanish Edition)!
- David Hume: Historical Thinker, Historical Writer!
- The Obamacon’s Dilemma.
Unlike nationalists who esteem the role of the state or nation over the local or regional community, traditionalists hold up patriotism as a key principle. Traditionalist conservatives think that loyalty to a locality or region is more central than any commitment to a larger political entity. Traditionalists also welcome the value of subsidiarity and the intimacy of one's community, preferring the civil society of Burke's "little platoons" over the expanded state.
Alternately, nationalism leads to jingoism and views the state as abstract from the local community and family structure rather than as an outgrowth of these local realities. Traditionalist conservatism began with the thought of Anglo-Irish Whig statesman and philosopher Edmund Burke , whose political principles were rooted in moral natural law and the Western tradition. Burke believed in prescriptive rights and that those rights were "God-given".
He defended what he referred to as "ordered liberty" best reflected in the unwritten law of the British constitutional monarchy.
The Dilemmas of American Conservatism
He also advocated for those transcendent values that found support in such institutions as the church, the family and the state. In Reflections , Burke called for the constitutional enactment of specific, concrete rights and warned that abstract rights could be easily abused to justify tyranny. American social critic and historian Russell Kirk wrote: "The Reflections burns with all the wrath and anguish of a prophet who saw the traditions of Christendom and the fabric of civil society dissolving before his eyes". Burke's influence extended to later thinkers and writers, both in his native Britain and in continental Europe.
Burke's traditionalist conservatism found its fiercest defenders in three " cultural conservatives " and " critics of material progress ": Samuel Taylor Coleridge , Thomas Carlyle and John Henry Newman. According to traditionalist scholar Peter Viereck, Coleridge and his associate and fellow poet William Wordsworth began as supporters of the French Revolution and the radical utopianism it spawned. However, by their collection of poems, Lyrical Ballads , had rejected the Enlightenment thesis of reason over faith and tradition.
Coleridge's later writings, including Lay Sermons , Biographia Literaria and Aids to Reflection , justified traditional conservative positions on hierarchy and organic society, criticism of materialism and the merchant class and the need for "inner growth" that is rooted in a traditional and religious culture. Coleridge was a firm believer in social institutions and a harsh critic of Jeremy Bentham and his utilitarian philosophy. Writer, historian and essayist Thomas Carlyle was also an early traditionalist thinker, defending medieval notions such as aristocracy, hierarchy, organic society and class unity over socialism and the "cash nexus" of laissez-faire capitalism.
According to Carlyle, the "cash nexus" was when social relationships were merely reduced to economic gain. A champion of the poor, Carlyle believed that the fabric of British society was being threatened by mobs, plutocrats, socialists and others who wanted to exploit them and perpetuate class resentment. A devotee of Germanic culture and Romanticism , Carlyle is most known for his writings Sartor Resartus — and Past and Present In the midth century, the Church of England experienced a "catholic revival" in the form of the Oxford Movement , a religious movement designed to restore the Catholic nature of Anglicanism.
Led by John Keble , Edward Pusey and John Henry Newman , the Tractarians so called for the publication of their Tracts for the Times condemned religious liberalism while defending "dogma, ritual, poetry, [and] tradition". Like Coleridge and Carlyle, Newman who became a Roman Catholic in and eventually a Cardinal in the Church and the Tractarians were critical of material progress, or the notion that wealth, prosperity and economic gain were the sum of human existence.
Culture and the arts were also important to British traditionalist conservatives and two of the most prominent defenders of tradition in culture and the arts were Matthew Arnold and John Ruskin. Matthew Arnold , a poet and cultural critic, is best known for his poetry and literary, social and religious criticism. His book Culture and Anarchy took on the middle-class Victorian values of the day Arnold viewed middle class tastes in literature as " philistinism " and argued for a return to the classical literature of the past. Arnold also viewed with skepticism the plutocratic grasping in socioeconomic affairs which Coleridge, Carlyle and the Oxford Movement criticized.
He ridiculed William Ewart Gladstone and Liberal efforts to disestablish the Anglican Church in Ireland, establish a Catholic university there, permit burial services to dissenters in Church of England cemeteries, demand temperance, and ignore the need to improve the middle class members rather than impose their unreasonable beliefs on society. Liberal education was essential, and by that Arnold meant a close reading and attachment to the cultural classics, coupled with critical reflection.
He was appalled at the shamelessness of the sensationalistic new journalism of the sort he witnessed on his tour the United States in He prophesied, "if one were searching for the best means to efface and kill in a whole nation the discipline of self-respect, the feeling for what is elevated, he could do no better than take the American newspapers. One of the themes that traditionalist conservatives have consistently reiterated has been the theme that industrial capitalism is as questionable as the classical liberalism which spawned it.
Carrying on in this tradition was cultural and artistic critic John Ruskin , a medievalist who called himself a "Christian socialist" and cared much for standards in culture, the arts and society. For Ruskin as with all the 19th-century cultural conservatives , the Industrial Revolution had fomented dislocation, rootlessness and the mass urbanization of the poor. In his art criticism, he wrote The Stones of Venice — , which took on the Classical tradition while defending Gothic art and architecture. In politics, the ideas of Burke, Coleridge, Carlyle, Newman and other traditionalist conservatives were distilled into the policies and philosophy of former British Prime Minister Benjamin Disraeli.
Disraeli in his younger years was an opponent of middle class capitalism and the industrial policies that were promoted by the "Manchester liberals" the Reform Bill and the Corn Laws. Seeking a way to alleviate the suffering of the urban poor in the wake of the Industrial Revolution, Disraeli sought out to unify the nation by way of " one-nation conservatism ", where a coalition of aristocrats and the common working man would unite to stave off the influences of the liberal middle class. This new coalition would serve as a way to work with the enfranchised masses while grounding them in "ancient conservative traditions".
Disraeli's ideas including his criticism of utilitarianism found fruit in the "Young England" movement and in writings such as Vindication of the English Constitution , The Radical Tory and his "social novels" Coningsby and Sybil In the early 20th century, traditionalist conservatism found its defenders through the efforts of Hilaire Belloc , G. Chesterton and other proponents of the socioeconomic system they advocated: distributism. Originating in the papal encyclical Rerum novarum , distributism employed the concept of subsidiarity as a "third way" solution to the twin evils of socialism and capitalism.
It favors local economies, small business, the agrarian way of life and craftsmen and artists.
In such books as Belloc's The Servile State , Economics for Helen and An Essay on the Restoration of Property and Chesterton's The Outline of Sanity , traditional communities that echoed those found in the Middle Ages were advocated and big business and big government condemned. Schumacher and were comparable to the work of Wilhelm Roepke. Eliot was a champion of the Western tradition and orthodox Christian culture. Eliot was a political reactionary who used modernist literary means for traditionalist ends.
Chesterton and Hilaire Belloc.
The Dilemmas of American Conservatism by Kenneth L. Deutsch (ebook)
Praised by T. Eliot as the most powerful intellectual influence in Britain, historian Christopher Dawson is a key figure in 20th-century traditionalism. Central to his work was the idea that religion was at the heart of every culture, especially Western culture and his writings, including The Age of Gods , Religion and Culture and Religion and the Rise of Western Culture , reflected this view. A contributor to Eliot's Criterion , Dawson believed that after World War II, religion and culture were central to rebuilding the West in the wake of fascism and the rise of communism.
British philosopher, Roger Scruton , is a self-described traditionalist conservative. Known for writing on such topics as foreign policy, animal rights, arts and culture and philosophy, one of his most noted books is The Meaning of Conservatism Recently British philosopher Phillip Blond has risen to prominence as an exponent of traditionalist philosophy, more specifically progressive conservatism, or Red Toryism.
In this Book
In Blond's view, Red Toryism would combine civic communitarianism with localism and traditional values as a way to revitalize British conservatism and British society. He has formed a think tank, Res Publica. The oldest traditionalist conservative publication in the United Kingdom is The Salisbury Review , which was founded by British philosopher Roger Scruton.
The Salisbury Review' s current managing editor is Merrie Cave. Within the British Conservative Party there is a faction of traditionalist MPs which formed in who are collectively known as the Cornerstone Group. The Cornerstone Group stands for traditional values and represents "faith, flag, and family".
The Edmund Burke Foundation is an educational foundation based out of the Netherlands which is traditionalist and is modeled after the Intercollegiate Studies Institute. Originally a think tank, it was founded by such traditionalists as scholar Andreas Kinneging and journalist Bart Jan Spruyt. It is affiliated with The Center for European Renewal. In , a number of leading traditionalist scholars from Europe as well as representatives of the Edmund Burke Foundation and the Intercollegiate Studies Institute created the Center for European Renewal , which is designed to be the European version of the Intercollegiate Studies Institute.
A major funder of traditionalist programs, especially the Russell Kirk Center, is the Wilbur Foundation. Literary traditionalist are often linked with political conservatives and the right-wing while contrasted with experimental works and the avant-garde , which in turn are often linked with progressives and the left-wing. Postmodern writer and literary theorist John Barth , said: "I confess to missing, in apprentice seminars in the later s and the s, that lively Make-It-New spirit of the Buffalo Sixties.
A roomful of young traditionalists can be as depressing as a roomful of young Republicans". Mallock , Robert Frost and T. Kirk was also known himself as a writer of supernatural and suspense fiction with a distinct Gothic flair. Kirk was also good friends with many literary figures of the 20th century: T.
The British novelist and traditionalist Catholic Evelyn Waugh is often considered a traditionalist conservative. From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia. Political ideology.